Asian Regionalism

Asia-Pacific regionalism has been spurred by increasing economic integration but pulled apart by territorial tensions. These two trends have proceeded on separate paths with only occasional intersection.  However, security dynamics are likely to increasingly influence regionalism as China rises and the US attempts to “pivot” more of its foreign policy to Asia.  ASEAN continues to serve as a base for regional organizations, but in 2012 questions were raised about whether that center could hold.   ASEAN’s goal to complete the blueprint for the ASEAN Free Trade Area in 2015 puts additional pressure on the group.  On a broader regional plane, the Trans-Pacific Partnership has expanded in recent months with the addition of Japan, Mexico, and Canada. Meanwhile, the launch of negotiations for the ASEAN-based Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership in late 2012 raises fears of a bifurcated landscape for the Asia-Pacific region into US and Chinese economic “spheres of influence.”

After a decade of rising regionalist aspirations and a flurry of community-building initiatives, the past year and a half has seen a slight shift in the momentum and direction of Asian regionalism.   While the signing of regional free trade agreements continues apace and discussions on regional cooperative mechanisms proceed unabated, the perceptions and political goals of many in the region have been recalibrated in the face of new challenges and new opportunities. By far, the biggest challenge was the global economic crisis, which had a mixed impact on Asian regionalism.  On one hand, it spurred calls for regional action, much in the way of the financial crisis that hit Asia hard in 1997-98.  Moreover, the relatively swift recovery of Asian economies seemed to highlight the fact that world economic power is shifting to East Asia.   On the other hand, crisis revealed the extent to which East Asia remains deeply integrated with the global economy, in both trade and finance, and it called into question the relevance of regional solutions for dealing with global challenges.

New opportunities arose with the election of new political leaders in Australia, Japan, and the US, each of whom placed regional initiatives high on their political agenda. Australia’s Kevin Rudd and Japan’s Hatoyama Yukio laid out competing grand visions for regional architecture that engaged Asian diplomats and policy analysts in lofty and abstract debates about institutional design and the proper membership and pacing for community-building. The change in the US had an even greater impact on regional dynamics.  After years of Bush administration policies that were perceived, fairly or not, as showing a lack of US interest in regional engagement, the Obama team took every opportunity to deliver the message that “the US is back” in Asia.  Its outreach to ASEAN has been particularly aggressive, raising the hopes and expectations of those who would like to see greater US involvement in regional community-building.

On the ground, however, progress on achieving tangible cooperation in regional frameworks, both trans-Pacific and East Asian, has been meager at best.  The global economic crisis gave rise to the G20 that, while elevating the symbolic weight of Asian economies in global governance, has also created institutional competition for regional frameworks.  Regional economic integration faces emerging and unresolved challenges, as the noodle bowl of bilateral free trade agreements (FTAs) grows more tangled and the impact of Chinese economic competition deepens.  Meanwhile, effective frameworks for multilateral security cooperation remain elusive.

Daily Digest

The Diplomat: Pacific Partnership 2019 Search and Rescue Exercise Comes to the Marshall Islands

US demonstrates commitment to security cooperation with Pacific Island states through Pacific Partnership exercise with the Marshall Islands.

The Diplomat: Are the US and China About to Face-Off Over American Fighter Sales to Taiwan?

An assessment of the implications if the US goes through with the sale of fighter aircraft to Taiwan.

The Diplomat: India-Indonesia Naval Patrols Highlights Maritime Collaboration

A reminder of the growing defense relationship between India and Indonesia.

The Diplomat: Japan Should Stop Acting Like China in Cambodia

Calling out Japan for ignoring Cambodia’s human rights abuses.

The Diplomat: China’s Weaponization of Market Access Might Backfire

An explanation of the risks associated with China’s decision to restrict market access of Canadian traders as retaliation for the arrest of Meng Wanzhou.

The Strategist: The ‘regime security dilemma’ in US–China relations

An argument for why the sustainability of the Chinese Communist Party plays a significant role in shaping the US-China rivalry.

East Asia Forum: Realising smart cities in ASEAN

Growing pains associated with “Smart Cities” initiative in Southeast Asia.

The Diplomat: Sri Lanka Will Get a $3.9 Billion Refinery Next to China-Run Hambantota Port

Could Sri Lanka’s Hambantota port become a case of “build it and they will come”?

South China Morning Post: To reclaim Philippines from Beijing’s grasp, US must look beyond the South China Sea

An argument for why the US needs to go beyond security assurances and address economic relations with the Philippines.

The Diplomat: How Can Indonesia Take Advantage of the Belt and Road’s Opportunities?

Analysts explore ways that Indonesia can take advantage of China’s Belt and Road Initiative.