US - Taiwan

U.S.-Taiwan relations over the four years of Chen Shui-bian’s first term shifted unevenly between commitment and crisis. The Democratic Progressive Party’s (DPP) rise to power initially frightened U.S. policymakers, who feared the radicalism of a party long identified with independence.  They discovered that Chen could be pragmatic and willing to accept guidance from the U.S. Under both the Clinton and Bush administrations, Taiwan accordingly received significant support for reform and expansion of its military capabilities; support which sometimes exceeded what the DPP and the Taiwan military were prepared to accept. With the advent of the Bush administration, Taiwan enjoyed an era of unprecedented friendship in Washington, experiencing policies that accorded it more respect and dignity as well as greater access and a higher profile.  Chen, however, pushed the limits by taking several initiatives considered provocative by China and the U.S. without prior consultation with his U.S. supporters.  The result has been anger and friction with uncertain implications for the future.

The election of Chen Shui-bian as president of Taiwan in March 2000 brought the decades-old Kuomintang (KMT) monopoly of power on the island to an end. This peaceful transition from one political party to another signified passage of an important milestone in the achievement of full democracy and was greeted with enthusiasm in the United States. Washington’s pleasure with the growth of democratic institutions, however, was offset somewhat with trepidation as to what a DPP presidency would mean for peace and stability in the Taiwan Strait. Thus the U.S. encouraged and warmly welcomed Chen’s inaugural address in which he pledged his four “No’s” and one “Would-Not”: no declaration of independence, no change in the name of the government, no placing the two-state theory in the constitution, and no referendum on self-determination.  At the same time, he would not eliminate the National Unification Council and Guidelines. Indeed in the weeks before the inauguration, Chen persuaded Taiwan supporters in the U.S. Congress to put aside plans to press for passage of the controversial Taiwan Security Enhancement Act. Generally, he sought to broadcast a moderate image abroad and at home as a pragmatic, conciliatory lawyer rather than a pro-independence firebrand. Members of the Clinton administration, who had found the final months of Lee Teng-hui’s presidency alarming and difficult, began to relax.

Daily Digest

The Diplomat: Cracks Appear in the New Zealand-China Relationship

China-New Zealand relations: Are we seeing the limits of Chinese power based on economic influence?

East Asia Forum: Can Cambodian foreign policy find its feet?

Cambodia’s foreign policy: diversifying relations or distancing itself from the West?

Asia Times: No end to World War II in sight in the Kuril Islands

How did the US end up in the middle of the dispute between Japan and Russia over the Northern Territories/Kuril Islands?

Asia Times: Morrison misconnects across the South Pacific

Engaging with the Pacific Island states will require more than just “showing up.”

The Diplomat – An American Consensus: Time to Confront China

A pessimistic view of US-China relations: Trump’s hardline policies are more deep-seated in the US than China realizes.

The Diplomat: China and the US Are Destined for Peace, Not for War

An optimistic view of US-China relations: the trajectory toward a mutual interest in peaceful coexistence is too great to be disturbed by Trump’s short-term focus.

The National Interest: Re-Opening the Kaesong Industrial Zone Would Give North Korea Something for Nothing

Would re-opening the Kaesong Industrial Zone at this point give North Korea an undeserved advantage over South Korea?

The Strategist: Improving maritime security in the Asia–Pacific

An argument for why a European solution to maritime domain awareness would not be a good solution for the Asia-Pacific.

The Interpreter: Philippine alliance angst

Is Defense Secretary Lorenzana’s call to review the US-Philippine Mutual Defense Treaty a case of being too clever by half?